null Skip to main content
FREE Shipping over $79Chanukah gelt 10% off · code GELT10 · order by Dec 1 East Coast / Nov 29 elsewhereChanukah gelt 10% off · code GELT10Order by Dec 1 East Coast / Nov 29 elsewhere
← Back to blog

Holiday Baking Checklist: What to Buy in Bulk (2026)

Posted by Whole And Natural · 1st Nov 2026

Holiday Baking Checklist: What to Buy in Bulk (2026)

Cookie season runs on the same handful of basics: sugar, flour, butter, chocolate chips, vanilla and nuts. Run out of one mid-batch and the whole afternoon stalls. The fix is simple. Buy the basics once, in bulk, in early November, and bake straight through the holidays.

Here's the checklist we'd stock up on, with today's prices and links to each item.

The holiday baking checklist

  • Brown sugar, powdered sugar and granulated sugar
  • All-purpose flour (plus almond flour for macarons and gluten-free bakes)
  • Baking powder and yeast
  • Pure vanilla extract and ground cinnamon
  • Chocolate chips
  • Pecans and walnuts
  • Butter and eggs (buy these fresh the week you bake)

How much to buy

A classic chocolate chip cookie recipe uses about 2 1/4 cups of flour, 3/4 cup each of white and brown sugar, a teaspoon of vanilla and 2 cups of chips. A 5 lb bag of flour holds roughly 18 cups, so it covers about 8 batches. If you bake for a crowd, or for gifts, the bulk sizes below are the ones that last until January.

Sugars

Brown sugar does the heavy lifting in cookies and blondies, and powdered sugar covers frosting, glazes and that snowy dusting on top. A big bag of cane sugar takes care of everything else. Keep brown sugar in an airtight container so it stays soft.

Flour and leavening

All-purpose flour handles cookies, pie crust and quick breads. Superfine almond flour is the one for macarons, almond cakes and gluten-free baking. Check the date on your baking powder before the season starts; an old can is the usual reason cookies come out flat. Yeast is for the rolls, challah and cinnamon buns.

Flavor and mix-ins

A 16 oz bottle of pure vanilla lasts through every batch of the season. Saigon cinnamon is warm and strong, which makes it perfect for snickerdoodles, apple pie and cinnamon rolls. Grab more chocolate chips than you think you need; somebody always eats a handful.

Nuts

Pecans go into pie, sandies and candied pecans. Walnuts go into brownies, banana bread and baklava. Store opened bags in the freezer and they'll keep well into the new year.

Before you bake: a quick plan

  • Early November: order the dry basics on this list, so nothing runs out mid-season.
  • Two weeks out: pick your recipes and check spices and baking powder.
  • The week of: buy butter and eggs, then bake the doughs that freeze well first.

Looking for more? Browse all our baking ingredients or nuts and seeds.

Orders of $79 or more ship free, and every order comes with 30-day returns. Questions about an item? We're Whole And Natural, shipping from Brooklyn, NY since 2007, and happy to help.

💬 Text us — we reply fast! (718) 568-9195

Text us