Stocking Stuffers Under $25: 10 Ideas for 2026

The stocking is the best part of the morning: small, fun and a little surprising. These 10 stocking stuffers are all under $25, all in stock and all ready to ship.

Tip: a few of the multi-packs split nicely across several stockings, so one order can fill the whole mantel.

For the candy fan

BeanBoozled is the stocking stuffer that turns into a game before breakfast: spin, eat a bean, and find out if it's Juicy Pear or Booger. Bertie Bott's beans are the Harry Potter version, every flavour included. For the less adventurous, there's always Mike and Ike and soft fruit taffy.

Holiday classics

A good Swiss chocolate bar and enough hot cocoa packets to last until New Year's.

For the grown-ups

Small and useful wins here: a tube of L'Occitane hand cream for winter hands and a stash of peppermint gum for the car.

For the kids

Individually wrapped marshmallow treats and a bag of Drizzilicious birthday cake bites, the sweet crunchy snack kids reach for first.

Stocking stuffer tips

• Mix one fun, one sweet and one useful in each stocking.
• Buy the multi-packs and split them: one 24-count box of Mike and Ike covers a whole family.
• Order early in the month so everything arrives well before the holidays.

More ideas: candy and chocolate and gifts and holidays.

Orders of $79 or more ship free, and every order comes with 30-day returns. Questions about an item? We're Whole And Natural, shipping from Brooklyn, NY since 2007, and happy to help.